Episode VII came out in December of 2015, three and a half years ago. It was the first live-action Star Wars film in theaters since 2005. I remember going to watch it at least three or four times. I was fascinated. Yesterday, I watched it again, and I can confirm it holds up.
First of all, old vs new. This film was written by Michael Arndt [Little Miss Sunshine (2006) and Toy Story 3 (2010)], J.J. Abrams [Super 8 (2011) and Mission Impossible III (2006)] and Lawrence Kasdan, the writer of, arguably, the best two Star Wars films ever made, Empire Strikes Back (1980) and Return of the Jedi (1983). If a man knows how to structure a Star Wars film, that’s Lawrence Kasdan. This film feels Star Wars from beginning to end, and we can see it in the structure. The underachieving, lonely hero (Luke, Rey) receives a call for action that pushes him/her into adventure (Leia’s hologram, the map to Luke). He meets a group of misfits (Han & Chewie in both movies, Finn in the Force Awakens, Obi Wan in A New Hope). Then, along the way, they must escape the dangers of outer space, until finally reaching their destination, with sets-up for the climax in the third act (destroying the Death Star, destroying the Starkiller base as well as rescue Rey). What I love about this structure is how it respects the original but also dares to twist it just enough. Unlike The Last Jedi, this film isn’t radically different, which was one of the main complains. In my opinion, this was no mistake. This was done on purpose, so it wouldn’t feel like the prequels felt; like The Last Jedi felt, where they try very hard to be different when they don’t get that opportunity. Let me explain. One can write an original film and twist clichés or common tropes, and it can be a huge success. Writers don’t get to do that with Star Wars, because they’re working over something the audience is very familiar with, and has strong expectations on it. Kasdan, Arndt and Abrams knew that. This was no accident. But this was no laziness either. This was a smart, thoughtful decision.
The new characters. Now, let’s avoid confusion here. This has similarities with the originals, no doubt. But this is no remake. We deal with very different characters. Where Luke was a whiny, know-it-all adolescent, Rey is a humbler, more empathic hero that dreams high (and yes, Rey is easier to empathize with than Luke). And we’re shown this when she eats her portions outside a destroyed AT-AT and puts on an old rebellion helmet. We’re shown this when she sees BB-8 in trouble and goes to rescue him. Then , reluctantly, let’s him stay for the night. We see this, when she refuses to exchange the droid to Unkar Plutt for 60 portions! This particular scene works because we had been set-up to the fact that the most she gets is half a portion. Unlike with Luke, where it was just fear that was holding him back, we get a more tangible reason as to why she wants to stay at Jakku. She’s feels her parents will come back any day soon, and she wants to be there to receive them and see them again. This is her arc, her internal need. Next is Kylo. He’s no Darth Vader. He even gets an internal motivation greater than ‘being evil’. He wants to be as great as his grandfather. He wants to prove himself. He fears to fail. He’s insecure, afraid, and he hides that behind his mask. There’s still light in him. He’s not as powerful as Vader, and that’s why Rey, who we had already been told had something special inside her (in a conversation between Snoke and Kylo, actually) is able to defeat him. The moment when he kills Han, is extremely powerful, because we get to see there’s still light in him. There’s a real struggle in killing his own father. This is not a pleasing experience for him. We can see the pain. Finn has also a greatly defined character. I find his comedy the most effective. He’s just a deserting stormtrooper, who wants to get as a far from the First Order as he possibly can. When he’s fleeing with Poe in the TIE, and Poe says he wants to go to Jakku, Finn’s reaction feels authentic. When he pretends to be a resistance member just to impress Rey, because he likes her, that feels authentic. Steve Kaplan, in his book “The Hidden Tools of Comedy”, mentions the best comedy appears when it comes from character and when you let your character try to win. Finn is a desertor, he wants to flee, so when he knows Poe will take them to Jakku, his reaction of disappointment and frustration feel authentic, that’s good comedy. Finn likes Rey, so the writers let him try to win by letting him pretend to be this important, noble guy to impress her. Now, granted, Finn is used as sort of a plot-convenient character who knows where everything is in the First Order, but I don’t see it as bad. If he wasn’t there, we would just get that the resistance had access to the database of the Starkiller base or that they got an informant from the inside, so I don’t see using Finn this way as a flaw. In fact, I think it strengthens the plot.
The classic characters. Episode VII had a very important task to do. Re-set-up for us the old characters we knew and loved. The script had to show us how they aged, while keeping it realistic to their characters. Han and Chewie went back to smuggling. I feel this as a great choice. “I went back to the only thing I was ever any good at.” says Han to Leia. He’s still the cynical cowboy. Except, he’s changed. He knows all the force mumble-jumble turned out to be true after all. He has a son that turned evil. He had a wife he loved but, after the past events, they had to go their own ways to deal with the pain. Han & Chewie’s return to the Millenium Falcon is one of the best scenes. Nostalgia hit me hard on that one. Han also got the chance to shoot at Kylo when he was taking Rey in Maz’ castle, but didn’t have the strength to do so. Leia is no longer a queen, but a general. She’s still fighting for what she believes. Unlike Han, she doesn’t get too much screen time. I think this is right. Abusing of the old characters would have taken them from iconic and legendary to overused, and would’ve stolen the thunder from the new heroes. The main reason why Han gets so much screen time, besides being a sort of mentor for the new heroes, is to set-up for his death. It impacts us even more to see him die after we shared not only the whole original trilogy with him, but this new adventure as well. Luke I don’t think there’s much to talk. He’s used more as a cliffhanger. I liked how the question was left as to ‘why did he leave’, I liked how the film ends when Rey returns Anakin’s lightsaber to him. C-3PO and R2-D2 have brief appearances. It’s sad to see R2 off, and it’s happy to see him on again near the end. I liked how 3PO is still the annoying, fearful droid we all hate and love.
The structure. The first act is quite long, around 30 minutes until Rey and Finn leave Jakku on the Millenium Falcon. It works, because we’re set-up to a lot of things ans because the story is always moving forward, right from the start. This duration shouldn’t scare us, since A New Hope‘s first act is around 40 minutes long. Then, we proceed to the adventures of the second act, where Rey and Finn leave Jakku, are swallowed by Han’s ship, then go to Maz Kanata after barely escaping from bounty hunters. In Maz’ castle, we get the midpoint of the story, which is when Rey has her visions with the lightsaber. The stakes are also raised, when some of the guests in the castle inform both the First Order and the Resistance that their droid is there. We see the starkiller base in use for the first time as it wipes out the planets of the republic. Finn, who was achieving his goal of fleeing to the Outer Rim, sees this and decides to stay. Rey and Kylo meet for the first time as we get an epic fight between good and evil, and Poe returns. Kylo takes Rey, Han meets with Leia in a very emotional moment. Meanwhile, Kylo fails to get information from Rey. She improves in her use of the force and gets a stormtrooper (Daniel Craig, no more no less) to free her. Finn helps the rebellion to plan the way into Starkiller. They get in and we learn that Finn doesn’t actually have much of an idea as to how to lower the shields, and reveals he’s just there to save Rey (“We’ll use the Force” “That’s not how the Force works!”). Then, they meet with Rey, plant bombs on the base, Han meets with Kylo, who kills him in the All is Lost Moment, right before the climax. Finn, and then Rey, fight Kylo and defeat him. They flee back to the rebellion hideout after the starkiller base is blown up. R2 comes back to life, the map is complete and we get the final scene when Rey meets with Luke. The film is very well structured, the plot points are all there, the story’s always moving forward, always dealing with the characters motivations and fears, like when Han offers Rey a job (“You’re offering me a job.” “I’m thinking about it”), but although she really wants it, she rejects it, because she still feels tied to Jakku. This is the kind of decisions that shape a character. It’s not from dialogue, but from actions and choices.
Overall, I think the movie is great. I know I’m not 100% objective, how could I? But, in my best attempt to be so, I see the movie as an exciting, emotional journey from beginning to end, with endearing characters, old and new, that keep you hooked to the story at all times. If you haven’t, you definitely should check it out, even if you’re not a Star Wars fan.
Thanks for reading,
The Screenplayer.